No side by side but here are some worns of each. 75K Castle first…
My choice would be my Castle for overall worn accuracy 
Two more
(Creep pictured first here)
Another set
(Creep first here too)
Creep first
Amazing pix brother!! And 75k Castle all the way 
I like the eyes on the creep better. Much more sinister looking. Also like the cleaner look personally. Never cared much for the flesh tones even though they are more accurate. Can’t really go wrong with either of these copies though. They both look amazing!
Thanks guys 
Both are great and I’m actually looking to pick up a Creep in the future. With that said, its hard to deny the accuracy of the 75K Castle when worn
75K Castle
I really like both but creep does look better
That is a top-shot there Mike 
Wow…
Yeah I’ve commented on this before. Just to reiterate, I have both of these and love them both. That being said. I still think after the 2 years I’ve had them both, that the Castle 75K SE is a bit better. This is always of course, subjective.
Thanks Jay! 
I think the creep is drastically better. Nag masks just aren’t my thing. I love all of Justin’s work except for the lunatic
Stock 75Ks straight from Nikos just don’t do it from me. JC 75Ks are on a whole other level. I adore N.O. Creeps. I currently own two; a 2012 and a 2019. Love 'em both.
Sent from my SM-S367VL using Tapatalk
\
You hit the nail right on the head brother. No offense to Nikos, the sculps are great …but I don’t like his finishing and eye cuts at all…the “stock 75ks” as you said don’t do it …when you see or are fortunate enough to have a James finished 75k whether it’s H1 or H2 there’s no going back after that . Seriously . You can’t own a JC NAG 75K then go back to a 75K finished by Nikos…I mean u can but it’s not the same or on the same level…
Nothing beats a creep imo 
it’s the king of all Myers masks
Well, that and a good ole Psycho done by JC
Absolutely agree 100%
Creep stock eyecuts always look too big and round to me. Nikos’ eyecuts have not always been perfect, but they are rarely too large so they can be adjusted. Every so often I see a Creep worn or stuffed properly with good eyecuts that looks really good, but almost every NAG 75k Castle I see look great, and in the hands of someone like Jimmy Falco or James Carter the 75k is perfection to me.
Couldn’t agree more! I’ve got a 75k castle blank with Freddy loper right now and I can’t wait for it!
I’ve owned both. A 2011 Creep (which I wish I still had) and a 75K Castle SE and I do prefer the Castle I believe. It may be a bit of an unfair comparison since the Castle was re-hauled by Freddy Loper, but there is something about the sculpt that I like just a fraction more.