Just curious, what is everyone’s most underrated and most overrated mask. This isn’t intended to start controversy but rather just see what folks prefer and don’t prefer. I would think factors would include price, ability to be converted, availability, etc.
I think the H78 is the most overrated, and the Knife Wielder and/or the Classic 75 are the most underrated.
I dont think its possible to “Overrate” a properly converted H78 ? IMO.
Pics of the masks we post would be sweet lol. 
The Knife Wielder is one of my all time favorites! Easily one of the most under rated masks out there! Another under rated mask is Dela Torre’s H1, its honestly one of my top 5 favorite Myers masks out there to this day and Im more than honored to own one!
warlock … so overrated, i never could understand what ppl saw in that mess of a mask.
As far as Kirkverted masks go… when I think of an underrated mask I’m thinking of masks that were not hyped to insane proportions and people have done great things with…
Underrated… Killing Machine, Dela Torre H1, Closet Monster, Original Nightmare, Knife Weilder and Tony
Honorable mentions… The Butcher, Lunatic and Crapface
Overrated masks to me were masks that it seemed like everyone was going bonkers over or were priced to gouge some even before they were complete.
Overrated… Nemesis, Fear, St. Nick, October 78 and Red October
*THESE ARE MY OPINIONS NOT FACTS 
MOST UNDERATED
FEAR
H78 RETOOL
GHASTLY KILLER
NAG H4 COVER MASK
THE HIRO
OVERRATED
SECOND STAB
DB2
*
Agreed, but I wouldn’t consider it a “Mess of a mask”
The Killing Machine, 31, and Dela Torre, and the anything by Tommy is horribly underrated!
As far as H1 goes, I think the Psycho is highly overrated, as for underrated, I’d have to go with the NAG Cover mask.
MAN THE PSYCHO ON THE BANNER AS H1 FOR A REASON THE PSYCHO IN MY EYES IS CLOSELY THE BEST H1 MASK MADE JMO
COME ON 
I agree with Jackcapers about the Psycho. You guys have to remember that these are OPINIONS
I personally never saw what seemingly everyone else does in that mask. There was always something just off about it in my eyes. It’s a nice mask, don’t get me wrong, it’s just not my style.
I think the DP 85 “the mask” is under rated 
Personally, I dont think it resembles the mask in H1 very well at all. It is used for the H1 button, but that doesnt make it the best man, it just means whoever decided for those pictures liked it, I mean, is the Warlock the best H2 mask out there? Not at all, so you cant base it off of that. In the end youll see what you see just as I will 
Overrated - Psycho
Underrated - Nightmare
Interesting stuff guys, for me, I’d have to say the most overrated is by far the DB2. Just does nothing for me and I think I would need to see one in person maybe to give it more respect. As for underrated, I don’t think the Maniac gets as much love as it should. It is one of the best masks ever made and can pull off several different looks of several different scenes.
Honorable mention: overrated-Nemesis
underrated-Psycho 81
Overrated - I’d have to say the psycho, I’m sure if I owned one or saw one in person I might have a different opinion, but for now, it is what it is.
Underrated - Maniac and H4 cover mask. I love the early run maniac I just receieved this past week, I don’t think it gets enough respect.
AGREED IF YOU HAVE A PSYCHO IN PERSON IT’S PRETTY HARD TO IGNORE HOW GOOD IT REALLY IS PICS DON’T DO IT JUSTICE @ ALL, DONE RIGHT IT PULLS OFF ALOT OF KEY SCENES IN H1 BUT I DO AGREE IT’S NOT THE BEST OF THE BEST BUT ONE IN MY EYES JMO
GREAT THREAD
TAKE CARE,
JIM
The CGP Fear and Warlock, NAG H78 and Classic are overrated masks in my opinion.
I think the nemesis is very underated, as far as overated i would say h78 or kh/dw those 2 just doesnt do it for me.
I’d say overated is an opinion based on preference and I’d say underrated is also an opinion based on preference.
On that note, there are more talked about masks on here than others.
For me its simply this…
What mask gives me that original H-1 chill I got, when I saw that wicked flick for the first time???
J
i might get a haymaker for this but i think the DB2 is overated(not my cup of tea)
underated would be one of the first myers we had available…NO NMM(the original 5 run) i owned 2 of them one being justins copie. may have been rough pulls, but they made a hell of a myers…maby mike d can shed some light on this 
mo